This roundtable discussion among airgun experts, including "the godfather of airguns" Tom Gaylord, delves into the nuances of airgun maintenance, challenging common assumptions about frequent cleaning. While many believe regular cleaning is essential for airguns, the experts generally agree that airguns are largely self-cleaning through use, and over-cleaning can even negatively impact accuracy. The primary focus of maintenance shifts from bore cleaning—which often removes harmless pellet residue rather than dirt—to addressing specific issues like performance degradation or external exposure to the elements. Key distinctions are made for different airgun types: CO2 guns require lubrication of cartridges and removal of small cartridges after use to prevent seal wear, while PCPs benefit from retaining some pressure to protect internal seals and prevent dust intrusion. The discussion also highlights the importance of following manufacturer guidelines for cleaning when available, using appropriate tools and lubricants like bore whips and silicone oil, and protecting guns from moisture and rust with products like Ballistol, especially after exposure to inclement weather. The experts strongly advise against using cleaning pellets due to their ineffectiveness and potential to damage certain gun components.